WLE Mekong
  • About Us
    • About us
      • Our objectives
      • Our team
      • Contact us
    • Our partners
        • Cambodian Partners
        • Chinese Partners
        • International Partners
        • Lao Partners
        • Myanmar Partners
        • Thai Partners
        • Vietnamese Partners
    • Close
  • Changes
    • Where We Work
      • Irrawaddy River Basin
      • Mekong River Basin
      • Red River Basin
      • Salween River Basin
      • View all projects
    • Our Work
      • Benefit-sharing
      • Catchments & Landuse
      • Gender & Diversity
      • Research for Development
      • River Food Systems
      • River Monitoring
      • Water Governance
      • Capacity Building & Professional Development
    • Our Research
      • Greater Mekong Dams Observatory
      • State of Knowledge Series
      • Water Knowledge Series
      • Irrawaddy River Basin
      • Mekong River Basin
      • Red River Basin
      • Salween River Basin
    • Close
  • Dialogue
    • Stories
      • Irrawaddy River Basin
      • Mekong River Basin
      • Red River Basin
      • Salween River Basin
      • Mekong Citizen
    • Greater Mekong Fora
      • 2018 Greater Mekong Forum
      • 2017 Greater Mekong Forum
      • 2016 Greater Mekong Forum
      • 2015 Greater Mekong Forum
    • Close

Mekong Blog

  • Mekong River Basin

Where a river is deepest it makes the least noise

  • Stories
  • Greater Mekong Forums
  • Mekong Citizen

Where a river is deepest it makes the least noise

AdminNovember 25, 2013Mekong Blog, Mekong River Basin

By Emma Coats

After three and a half years working as a community engagement officer in the Murray-Darling Basin, Emma has recently moved to Laos and is currently working for CPWF.

Last year in Broken Hill, Australia, talking with river communities about Australia’s proposed Murray-Darling Basin Plan, Evelyn, an Indigenous elder, said to me:

Darling River, Australia/Emma Coats

Darling River, Australia/Emma Coats

If someone offered to pay me $1000 every day for the rest of my life to leave the Darling River, I would not.

The river is our home: our meeting place, our ceremony place, our swimming place, our supermarket. The river is everything.

I suspect it would not take long to find people along the Mekong and its tributaries who feel as deeply about their rivers. The Mekong is a region of river-based identities and livelihoods and has been for millennia.

Evelyn’s comment was made as part of a consultation between Indigenous people of the Murray Darling Basin and the Australian Government.  The discussion centred around better understanding indigenous needs for water.  It was set in the context of a potentially declining water supply (drought and climate change) and many competing uses for that limited and valuable water.

In Australia, there are many perspectives on water: who should own it, how it should be managed, and why it is important. These value perspectives are all valid points of view in the water debate. There are environmentalists, farmers, manufacturers, indigenous people such as Evelyn, urban water users, rural communities, and others. Sometimes their values and requirements align. Often they don’t.

Since moving to Laos, I have wondered if there are as many value perspectives in the Mekong basin as in the Murray-Darling Basin, despite the apparent differences between the two. Economic development through hydropower is a well-known point on the value scale here. The environment and its relation to food security is another point on that same scale. What about the values in between? The quieter voices?

Some of the CPWF Mekong projects ask and aim to answer these questions. One project aims specifically to document the many different values of water in the Mekong, and notes that this is critical for multi-stakeholder engagement and policy development. A CPWF small-grant project looks at the unique situation and perspective of fisherwomen in southern Laos. Another project looks at indigenous water values and exposes the low level of institutional knowledge about these values.

The ‘Mekong’ film airs many lesser known voices in the Mekong, such as the tourism industry, the children of fisher families who are now finding work in different industries, and indigenous minorities in Cambodia who will be displaced – along with 5000 villages – in anticipation of the Lower Se San 2 dam. A powerful quote from the film shares the indigenous sense of place, which reminds me of Evelyn’s attachment to the Darling River:

Mekong film screen shot / Indigenous communities of the Lower Se San

Mekong film screen shot / Indigenous communities of the Lower Se San

When the dam is built, my house and crops will be flooded. If I have to leave the village, I will lose everything, especially the spirits and culture. Why must I leave the bones of my parents, uncles and aunties here? I can’t leave. I refuse to go. Even in Pol Pot’s time we were able to live here.

The CPWF thai baan project is also committed to the quieter voices. This is displayed in its empowerment and education of local communities – in Cambodia, Laos and Vietnam – through film. Using thai baan – a participatory research approach – the project entrusts villagers to become local researchers who produce educational outputs for their communities. The project provides many interesting insights on impacted livelihoods (pre- and post-dams) and human resilience and adaptability in the face of change.

Through CPWF, these projects aim to increase knowledge, equity and understanding in the water debate. They increase the level of institutional knowledge about local experiences and diversify the media coverage. In turn, these voices rising from the deep help to paint the complex truth: that in the Mekong basin, as in every river basin, water has an economic, environmental, social, cultural, even spiritual and aesthetic value.

For Mekong governments, allowing many voices to be heard is difficult – as it must account for people’s livelihoods, cultural traditions and world views – but understanding different water values and uses is key to policy management and the long-term sustainability of a river basin. Policies run the risk of long-term failure if the people they affect have no buy-in. Working to understand these perspectives will take time and money in the first instance, but will also save time and money later.

Changes to a river system that will affect the lives of 70 million people is no small matter. Sooner or later the river shallows out and the rush of the rapids will be heard.

Previous
Story
Next
Story

Related Stories

  • mekong
    March 10, 2015
    Work begins on 30MW dam in Khammuan
  • mekong
    October 25, 2012
    Hydropower plants generate safe, clean energy: Deputy PM
  • mekong
    October 3, 2013
    Laos informs neighbours on hydro development
  • mekong
    February 5, 2015
    Energy tycoon Li Hejun ousts Jack Ma as China's richest man
  • mekong
    June 14, 2013
    Dam developer promotes better fishing practices
  • mekong
    November 22, 2012
    Laos responds to Xayaboury dam concerns
  • mekong
    September 14, 2012
    Laos clarifies Xayaboury dam development
  • mekong
    June 13, 2013
    Natural resources could pay for nationwide primary education: Report
  • mekong
    September 16, 2014
    Cambodia's River Coalition in Cambodia calls upon government to protect the Mekong River
  • mekong
    November 4, 2015
    The art of weaving: A unique research partnership in Viet Nam
  • mekong
    October 14, 2012
    Xayaboury dam powers rural area development
  • mekong
    May 2, 2013
    Lao officials to study sustainable hydro development in Australia
  • mekong
    January 19, 2016
    Impressions from a study trip to Laos - Le Phuoc Thao
    River Food Systems
  • mekong
    February 12, 2013
    Aquatic conservation project commences in Lower Mekong Basin
  • mekong
    April 24, 2014
    Study documents being processed for Nam Theun 2 expansion
  • mekong
    December 6, 2017
    Outrespecting the 2017 Forum
    Gender & Diversity | Water Governance
  • mekong
    February 24, 2014
    Hydropower has future potential in national development
  • mekong
    March 10, 2015
    Cambodia PM says work on mega-dam will not start until 2018
  • mekong
    February 2, 2015
    Fish fix adds B10bn to Xayaburi cost
  • mekong
    April 23, 2014
    Mekong nations commit to sustainability

The sustainable development of the Greater Mekong depends on the fair and equitable governance of its water.

ABOUT WLE

  • Our objectives
  • Our team
  • Our partners
  • Terms of use
  • Newsletters
  • Contact us

CO-SUPPORTED BY

WLE Greater Mekong is funded in part by the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT).

Water, Land & Ecosystems Mekong - footer logos
© All rights reserved - WLE CGIAR
Subscribe to our newsletter SIGN UP
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy policy